$1,800,000.00 | 5 bed 4 bath 4,814sqft 4,814 square feet 0.27acre lot | 255 W George Ave, Maitland, FL 32751.
Listed at Prime Holdings Inc
Email: broker@primeholdings.site
Property Type | Single family |
|---|---|
Price Per Sqft. | $374 |
Garage | 2 Cars |
Year Built | 1957 |
🌴 Elegant Maitland Retreat – Steps from Lake Sybelia
Discover timeless sophistication and modern luxury in this beautifully reimagined Maitland estate, just one block from the serene shores of Lake Sybelia. Fully renovated in 2007, this residence offers high-end finishes, exceptional flow, and curated details throughout.
A stately paver driveway welcomes you home, flanked by tropical landscaping, decorative stone accents, and a charming water fountain—all leading to a spacious two-car garage. Inside, the grand foyer impresses with soaring ceilings, intricate wrought iron railings, and streams of natural light.
The Great Room delivers both comfort and grandeur, with expansive windows, French doors opening to a resort-style backyard, and built-in ceiling speakers for immersive sound. Entertain with ease in the gourmet kitchen, complete with custom cabinetry, granite countertops, a farmhouse sink, and premium stainless steel appliances.
The adjacent dining room shines with hardwood floors, plantation shutters, integrated speakers, and direct outdoor access—perfect for indoor-outdoor hosting. A cozy first-floor family room offers tropical design accents, a built-in media center, and double-door access to your private retreat.
Upstairs, a bright loft space overlooks the main level, ideal as a reading nook or flex space. The primary suite is a true escape, featuring rich wood floors, a private balcony, speaker system, and a luxurious en-suite bath with a rain shower, clawfoot tub, dual vanities, and built-in seating.
Step outside to your personal oasis—featuring a resort-style pool, covered patio with stately columns, and a full-width balcony above. The lush backyard includes a pool house, abundant greenery, and generous space for entertaining in total privacy.
🏡 Property Features – 255 W George Ave, Maitland, FL 32751
🔹 Interior Details
Bedrooms: 5
Primary Bedroom: Second Floor
Guest Bedrooms: Mix of First & Second Floor
Bathrooms: 4 Full
Total Rooms: 12
Includes: Great Room, Living Room, Loft, Office/Study
Interior Features:
Open Floorplan w/ High Ceilings & Crown Molding
Built-In Features, Stone Counters & Solid Wood Cabinets
Eat-In Kitchen + Kitchen/Family Room Combo
Travertine & Hardwood Flooring
Plantation Shutters, Walk-In Closets, and Window Treatments
Thermostat, Ceiling Fans, Split Bedroom Layout
Appliances:
Refrigerator, Microwave, Range, Dishwasher, Disposal
Laundry Room with dedicated space
Climate Control:
Cooling: Central Air
Heating: Central, Electric
🔹 Exterior & Lot
Lot Size: 0.27 Acres (11,832 SqFt)
Construction: Block, Concrete, Stucco
Roof: Metal (Durable & Long-Lasting)
Built: 1957 | Total Living Space: 4,814 SqFt
Garage: 2-Car Attached w/ Oversized Driveway & Opener
Outdoor Features:
Covered Porch, Wraparound Patio, French Doors
Second-Floor Balcony, Deck, Rain Gutters
Private Mailbox, Storage, Mature Landscaping
Fenced-In Yard, Irrigation System
🔹 Pool & Spa
Private In-Ground Pool
Surrounded by lush greenery & multiple entertaining areas
📍 Location & Community
School Zone:
Lake Sybelia Elementary
Maitland Middle
Edgewater High
Neighborhood: Replat Blk B Poors Add
Zoning: RSF-2 | HOA Fees: None
Tax (2024): $7,138
Ownership: Fee Simple
Directions: From I-4 E, take Exit 90B → Lake Destiny Dr. → Sandspur Rd. → Maitland Ave. → Left on George Ave. Home is on the left.
💰 Monthly Payment Overview – 255 W George Ave, Maitland, FL
🏠 Home Price: $1,800,000
📅 Estimated Monthly Payment: $10,548
30-Year Fixed Mortgage @ 6.686%
📊 Monthly Breakdown
Category | Amount |
|---|---|
Principal & Interest | $9,279 |
Property Tax | $595 |
Home Insurance | $675 |
HOA Fees | $0 |
Mortgage Insurance | $0 |
🧾 Total Due at Closing
Cost | Amount |
|---|---|
Down Payment (20%) | $360,000 |
Estimated Closing Costs (4%) | $72,000 |
Total Due at Close | $432,000 |
📈 Price History – 255 W George Ave, Maitland, FL
Date | Event | Price | Price/SqFt | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Mar 27, 2025 | Listed | $1,800,000 | $374/sqft | +500% increase since 2004 |
Oct 26, 2004 | Sold | $300,000 | $62/sqft | Public Record |
1957 | Built | – | – | Original construction |
✅ Appreciation Highlight:
This property has appreciated +$1.5M since 2004, a 500% value increase, reflecting its extensive renovations and rising market appeal.
🧾 Tax History – 255 W George Ave, Maitland, FL
Year | Taxes | Total Assessment | Land | Additions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
2023 | $6,850 | $463,392 | – | – |
2022 | $6,422 | $449,895 | – | – |
2021 | $6,346 | $436,791 | – | – |
2020 | $6,041 | $429,774 | – | – |
2019 | $6,250 | $420,111 | – | – |
2018 | $6,214 | $412,278 | – | – |
2017 | $6,149 | $403,798 | – | – |
2016 | $6,085 | $395,403 | – | – |
2015 | $6,201 | $392,744 | – | – |
2014 | $6,245 | $388,627 | – | – |
2013 | $6,046 | $383,869 | – | – |
2012 | $6,083 | $377,452 | – | – |
2011 | $6,282 | $365,458 | – | – |
2010 | $6,186 | $361,042 | – | – |
2009 | $5,260 | $351,150 | – | – |
2008 | $5,306 | $305,199 | – | – |
2007 | $9,409 | $587,757 | – | – |
✅ Insight:
Over the last decade, this property’s assessed value and tax obligation have steadily increased, reflecting its enhanced condition and rising market value post-renovation.
The price and tax history data displayed is obtained from public records and/or MLS feeds from the local jurisdiction.
🌇 Neighborhood Overview – 255 W George Ave, Maitland, FL
🛍️ Nearby Amenities
Category | Score | Nearby Examples |
|---|---|---|
Daycares | 10/10 | Asbury Early Learning Center, Maitland Presbyterian Preschool (0.1–0.3 mi) |
Groceries | 8/10 | Maitland Farmer’s Market, Publix, Hollieanna Groves (0.3–0.5 mi) |
Shopping | 6/10 | Tom James Co, Lake Howell Square, Luna Upholstery (0.2 mi) |
Restaurants | 5/10 | Custom Cakes, Dippedbytash, Subway (0.2 mi) |
Cafés | 5/10 | 7-Eleven, Starbucks, McDonald’s (0.3 mi) |
Nightlife | 4/10 | Erik & Mike Music (0.1 mi) |
Parks | 4/10 | Quinn Strong Park (0.3 mi) |
🌿 Lifestyle Ratings
Aspect | Score | Details |
|---|---|---|
Wellness | 4/10 | Some amenities for physical activity and healthy eating nearby |
Vibrant | 3/10 | Calm, lightly active atmosphere |
Quiet | 2/10 | Many sources of nearby noise |
🚗 Transportation Scores
Mode | Score | Description |
|---|---|---|
Driving | 9/10 | Excellent access to highways and ample nearby parking |
Walking | 7/10 | Most daily errands within walking distance |
Transit | 5/10 | Some public transit available |
Cycling | 4/10 | Limited support for bike commuting or recreation |
✅ Summary:
This location delivers top-tier accessibility, family-friendly resources, and convenient walkability—ideal for both everyday living and long-term value.
🎓 Nearby Schools – 255 W George Ave, Maitland, FL
🏫 Public & Charter Schools
School Name | Grades | Distance | Rating | Reviews | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Lake Sybelia Elementary School | K–5 | 0.3 mi | 4/10 | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (11) | Public |
Maitland Middle School | 6–8 | 1.5 mi | 4/10 | ⭐⭐⭐ (13) | Public |
Edgewater High School | 9–12 | 3.8 mi | 4/10 | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (10) | Public |
Cornerstone Academy Charter | K–8 | 10.8 mi | 8/10 | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (28) | Charter |
Cornerstone Charter High School | 9–12 | 10.8 mi | 6/10 | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5) | Charter |
Winter Park High School | 9–12 | 4.2 mi | 6/10 | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5) | Public |
🏫 Private Schools Nearby
School Name | Grades | Distance | Rating | Reviews | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Maitland Montessori School | PK–8 | 0.4 mi | – | ⭐⭐⭐ (9) | Private |
Jewish Academy of Orlando | K–5 | 0.4 mi | – | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (33) | Private |
Celandine Life-Prep Academy Inc | 1–12 | 0.7 mi | – | ⭐ (0) | Private |
✅ Summary:
The home is zoned for solid foundational public schools and enhanced by access to top-rated charter and private institutions—a strong education mix in a family-friendly neighborhood.
🌿 Environmental Risk – 255 W George Ave, Maitland, FL
Risk Factor | Level | Details |
|---|---|---|
Flood Factor | Minimal | No changes expected; property not at high flood risk. |
Fire Factor | Minimal | Wildfire risk remains low and stable. |
Heat Factor | Severe | 7+ days projected above 107°F this year. |
Wind Factor | Extreme | High risk of severe wind events over the next 30 years. |
Air Factor | Minor | Slight increase in poor air quality risk. |
✅ Insight: While heat and wind exposure are notable, the home benefits from minimal flood and fire risks, making it a relatively secure investment from an environmental standpoint.
📊 Home Value – Prime Holdings Inc® Breakdown
Valuation Provider | Current Estimate | Earliest Historical Estimate (Mar 2020) | % Change | Last Year's Estimate (Mar 2024) | % Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Quantarium | $1,087,316 | $714,135 | +52.3% | $1,102,857 | −1.4% |
CoreLogic® | $1,580,700 | $868,400 | +82% | $1,219,200 | +29.7% |
Collateral Analytics | $834,000 | $473,982 | +76% | $1,030,000 | −19% |
✅ Summary Insight:
The CoreLogic estimate reflects the highest growth rate, showing strong appreciation and sustained demand.
Quantarium and Collateral Analytics offer conservative views, with slight short-term declines but long-term gains.
